Letters on Taxation
Letter 1
Edwin Burgess
[1859]
Being in the County Clerk's Room of the Court House, I saw a large
pile of papers headed "Statement of Property," to be filled
out and sworn to by every resident owner. "The number and value
of horses and cattle, mules and asses, sheep, hogs, pleasure carriages
of every description, watches, moneys and credits, merchant's stock,
manufacturer's stock and other articles of personal property;"
which is everything that one person could sue another for stealing.
Now, I could not help thinking somewhat on the cost as well as
consequence of such a method of Taxing People for the support of
Government.
1st. Taxing people for their personal property - on their oath, is a
premium on perjury, because those who lie the most, pay the least
taxes; and children born under such influences will be famous for
lying - if there is any connection between cause and effect in the
condition of parent and offspring.
2nd. The means of valuing or assessing are very expensive; thus
increasing the cost of government, as well as the cost of corruption.
3rd. Taxing personal property prevents production, because the tax
being added to the article for sale, increases its price in proportion
to the means of lying. Hence, less is sold and less is made, and the
makers are less employed; and having, consequently, less with which to
buy, the makers of other things will be less employed also - till the
surplus workers will become paupers, and suffer much misery in
consequence; many will become hopeless, and reckless because hopeless.
Some will be tempted to commit crime for the temporary alleviation of
their misery, which, repeated, soon becomes a habit; we have then
paupers and criminals to support, pauper houses and prisons to build,
officers to hire to superintend both; Legislators to make laws for
their government; thus the Tax on personal property, or the product of
industry, increases the amount of paupers and criminals, while the
cost of keeping paupers and criminals, officers and Legislators,
increases the amount of Tax and the cost of government, of course.
A friend of mine intended to buy a piano, but the Tax decided him
against it; fewer watches will be sold, because they are taxed. If any
person puts up a new fence, or make any visible improvement, which
employs the unemployed and prevents their continuance as paupers, and
beautifies the city - they are taxed annually in proportion to the
evil they prevent and the good they do.
4th. Taxing personal property is not only costly, corruptive, and
pauper-making, and promotive of misery and crime, but inquisitorial,
burdensome, and aggressive against our right to labour and enjoy the
fruit of our toil unmolested; as long as we injure no one, we should
be protected against aggression, instead of suffering aggression. Are
we not now taxed for the aggression instead of the protection against
it?
5th. Taxing people in proportion to their industry prevents industry;
because when an industrious person labours twelve hours per day,
successfully, he must pay twelve as much taxes, because he has made
twelve times as much property to be taxed, as if he had worked only
one hour per day; and besides the limit of his means to pay the tax,
whether in a watch, a piano, or a horse, no one likes to be taxed for
the idleness of others, and he feels the injustice also, and
improvements are thus prevented which would profitably employ the
idle.
6th. Taxing personal property raises the price of land, and thus
promotes its monopoly by the rich - because land being the source of
our subsistence, which labour develops or increases, from which, and
on which, all must live, and money instead of manhood being the
qualification for owning land, it follows that in proportion as the
taxes are on personal property, the land will be exempt, and it will
be thus, comparatively cheap, or easy for the rich to monopolize; so
that if all the taxes were on the land, it would sell for the lowest
price, and would be most difficult to monopolize; but if all the taxes
were on personal property, and none on the land, then the land would
sell for the highest price, and labour would sell for the lowest
price, because of the excessive competition of the landless and
destitute workers, who by selling their labour for the smallest
portion of its produce, would keep the land at the highest possible
price; so, when you want land to be low, and wages high, put all the
taxes on the land; but if you prefer labour to be low and land high,
you have only to put all the taxes on personal property. All articles
of productive industry cost the keeping of the maker and contriver,
but the land costs nothing for either. It is the natural inheritance
of all, for all time; and all should be protected in their possession,
and those who own all the land should certainly pay all the Taxes for
keeping them in possession and their neighbours out of it.
WAGES SLAVERY
Must not our southern lords be fools
To buy their slaves, when they're so plenty,
When stealing land by laws and rules,
And keeping poor folk's stomachs empty,
Would give them wages slaves for naught,
Who'd beg to have their labour bought;
And women, too, breathe soft the word,
Who'd sell their bodies for their board?
Our wages slaves ne'er run away,
The fear of starving makes them stay;
Though they must earn the daily bread
For others' mouths beside their own,
Who on the best are ever fed,
Aping the monarch on the throne;
Yet hirelings bowed with want and care
Are glad the coarsest food to share.
The keep of chattels is a bore,
When sick or they can work no more;
Without the lash to drive the work,
Chattels are very apt to shirk;
But the poor landless wages slave,
Must clothing, food, and shelter crave;
For these he works with willing hand
For any one by sea or land.
Then grasp the land, the source of wealth,
Of life, of energy, and health;
And only let the workers toil,
While you by law can reap the spoil.
What man or woman e'er so brave,
Will want not make a wages slave,
A slave in body and in mind,
To any tyrant of their kind?
INTRODUCTION
Letter 1
* Letter 2
* Letter 3
Letter 4
* Letter 5
* Letter 6
Letter 7
* Letter 8
* Letter 9
Letter 10
* Letter 11
|